Addiction Isn’t a Choice: Gabor Maté’s Bold Answers to Life’s Toughest Questions

Exploring trauma, society’s hidden toxins, and the path to true self-discovery with the renowned physician and thinker.

In a cozy Penguin studio in England, Gabor Maté sits down to dissect some of humanity’s thorniest dilemmas. If you’ve followed his work, you know he’s no ordinary expert. Born in Budapest in 1946, Maté’s early life was scarred by the shadows of World War II and the Holocaust—his grandparents perished in Auschwitz, and as an infant, he narrowly escaped a similar fate. Fleeing communist Hungary after the 1956 uprising, he grew up in Canada, eventually becoming a family doctor who specialized in addiction treatment. His books, like “In the Realm of Hungry Ghosts,” have reshaped how we think about substance use, trauma, and healing. But in this candid session, Maté goes deeper, challenging the very assumptions that prop up our legal systems, cultural norms, and even our understanding of divinity. As I listened to his words, I couldn’t help but wonder: in a world reeling from rising anxiety and isolation, are we finally ready to hear what he has to say?

Maté’s insights come at a pivotal moment. Globally, mental health landscape is in turmoil. The World Health Organization reports that depression and anxiety disorders affect over 500 million people worldwide, with rates climbing steadily since the pandemic. In places like the United States, where opioid crises have claimed hundreds of thousands of lives, and in Europe, amid economic uncertainties and migration stresses, these issues aren’t just statistics—they’re symptoms of something profoundly amiss. Maté, with his blend of medical expertise and lived pain, offers a compass through this mess. He doesn’t just diagnose; he provokes us to question why we’re all, in subtle ways, struggling to stay afloat.

The False Narrative Around Addiction

Let’s cut to the chase: is addiction really a choice? Maté dismantles this idea with the precision of someone who’s spent 12 years working in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside, once North America’s ground zero for open drug use and despair. There, among the heroin users and crack addicts, he encountered stories that defy the courtroom cliché that people “choose” their downfalls. “Nobody wakes up aspiring to break laws or ruin their health,” he says. Instead, addiction is a desperate bid to numb deep-seated wounds.

Drawing from his clinical encounters, Maté points out a chilling pattern: every female patient he treated had endured childhood sexual abuse, while the men carried layers of trauma from neglect, violence, or loss. Who, he asks rhetorically, picks that kind of start in life? This isn’t new ground—historically, addiction has been misunderstood for centuries. In the 19th century, opium dens in China sparked colonial wars that redrew geopolitical maps, fueling Britain’s imperial ambitions and China’s “Century of Humiliation.” Fast-forward to Nixon’s 1971 “war on Drugs,” which Maté labels a “criminal” approach, prioritizing punishment over compassion. This mindset, he argues, ignores brain science: trauma rewires neural pathways, making addictive behaviors a wired response rather than a willful act.

But Maté broadens the lens. Addiction isn’t confined to illicit substances; it’s any habit that delivers fleeting relief at a steep cost—think endless online shopping sprees, gambling binges, or workaholic burnout. In today’s gig economy, where precarious jobs breed stress, who hasn’t chased a dopamine hit from social media or comfort food? In the UK, soaring gambling addictions have prompted government interventions, while in the US, pornography and gaming disorders are quietly epidemic. Maté’s definition strips away stigma: craving, short-term escape, long-term harm, and the stubborn inability to quit. By this measure, we’re all on the hook in this high-stress society. It’s a sobering reflection—makes you pause and scan your own routines, doesn’t it? If we criminalize only street drugs, we’re hypocritically ignoring the boardroom obsessions that drive corporate exploitation across global supply chains.

Debunking the ‘Normal’ in Our World

This segues naturally into Maté’s core thesis: the “myth of normal.” What passes for everyday life in our societies isn’t just average—it’s often deeply unhealthy. He clarifies that “normal” is a statistical term, not a badge of well-being. Imagine a city where pet abuse was commonplace; abstaining would be “abnormal,” but that doesn’t make it right. In our case, cultural practices like cutthroat competition and isolation masquerade as virtues, eroding our health.

Historically, this disconnect traces back to the Enlightenment’s push for individualism, which accelerated during the Industrial Revolution. Factories uprooted communities, birthing modern alienation—a theme echoed in Marx’s critiques of capitalism. Today, geopolitical tensions amplify this: in conflict zones like Ukraine or the Middle East, trauma ripples through generations, mirroring Maté’s own Hungarian roots. Closer to home, Britain’s appointment of a “Minister for Loneliness” in 2018 underscores a epidemic of disconnection, while US stats show 70% of adults on at least one medication, half on two. Childhood ADHD diagnoses surge globally, autoimmune diseases climb, and kids now face adult metabolic issues amid obesity crises.

Maté insists these aren’t aberrations but predictable reactions to a toxic milieu. Pollutants poison our bodies, while emotional stressors—like relentless hustle—wreak havoc on minds. In a world of climate anxiety and economic inequality, is it any wonder anxiety is skyrocketing? His holistic view ties physiology to psychology: our bodies aren’t isolated; they’re intertwined with emotions shaped by society. From womb stresses (mothers’ anxieties imprinting fetuses) to lifelong relational strains, everything connects. Geopolitically, this matters—think how austerity policies in Europe or trade wars exacerbate mental health burdens, turning personal pain into public crises.

Society’s Role in Our Sickness

So, is our culture actively making us ill? Maté doesn’t mince words: yes. He paints a picture of a system that prioritizes profit over people, fostering isolation and competition. In the US, where healthcare is commodified, overmedication is rampant; in Asia’s high-pressure societies, suicide rates among youth highlight the toll. Even in welfare states like Scandinavia, rising depression suggests no escape from global capitalism’s grip.

Maté’s analysis echoes historical shifts: post-World War II consumerism promised fulfillment but delivered emptiness, as critiqued in books like Vance Packard’s “The Hidden Persuaders.” Today, amid climate change and pandemics, these flaws are magnified. Obesity epidemics stem from processed foods peddled by multinationals, while pollutants from industrial giants—often in developing nations—fuel autoimmune rises. Emotionally, the “ruthless competition” Maté decries isolates us, echoing geopolitical divides: think Brexit’s social fractures or US polarization.

Reflecting on this, it’s hard not to feel a pang of concern. If illness is a “normal response to an unhealthy culture,” as Maté claims, what does that say about our future? Yet, he offers hope: recognizing this myth is the first step toward change.

The Power of Becoming Ourselves

Can people truly transform? Maté flips the script: it’s not about changing who we are, but reclaiming our authentic selves. This culture, he argues, alienates us from our essence, breeding suffering. But yes, redemption is possible. Drawing from his own journey—from a “militant atheist” scarred by Holocaust trauma to a more spiritually open elder—Maté shares how he’s “ripened” over time.

He’s witnessed patients with grave illnesses use their conditions as catalysts for self-discovery, leading to healing. Historically, figures like Viktor Frankl, a Holocaust survivor, found meaning amid horror, influencing modern therapy. Geopolitically, resilience shines in post-conflict societies, like Rwanda’s reconciliation efforts. Maté’s message? Alienation hurts—mentally, spiritually, physically—but reconnecting fulfills a core human need.

Grappling with the Divine

Finally, does God exist? Maté, once a staunch atheist shaped by communist Hungary’s secularism and personal losses, now embraces a nuanced view. The anthropomorphic deity—omnipotent, omniscient, benevolent—never squared with Auschwitz’s horrors. Why allow such evil?

Yet, he’s evolved. God, for him, isn’t a distant ruler but the universe’s oneness, intelligence, and goodness—an experiential reality, not dogma. This shift resonates with historical mysticism, from Spinoza’s pantheism to Eastern philosophies influencing Western thought post-colonial exchanges. In a divided world, where religious conflicts rage in the Middle East or fuel populism elsewhere, Maté’s inclusive stance offers a bridge. It’s not belief, but lived holiness. Comforting, isn’t it, in these uncertain times?

A Call to Awaken

Gabor Maté’s reflections leave us with more questions than answers, but that’s the point. In a era of geopolitical upheaval—from wars displacing millions to inequalities breeding despair—his call to unmask the “myth of normal” feels urgent. We’ve built societies that sicken us, yet within lies the potential for healing through authenticity and connection. As Maté wraps up, promoting his book “The Myth of Normal,” one can’t help but reflect: if we’re all a bit addicted, a bit broken, perhaps the real choice is to wake up and become who we’re meant to be. It’s a daunting path, but as history shows, transformation often blooms from the darkest soil.

Scroll to top